A colleague was just told she cannot have her high school freshmen read The Autobiography of Malcom X this year, a book her students’ parents were likely to have been assigned when they were in school. This is in a blue state with no “divisive concepts” legislation passed. (Anne Lutz Fernandez, via Twitter)
And… there you go. It’s everywhere now, red states and blue. The fear, the anxiety, the confusion. The misinformation/disinformation/lack of information. A backlash to the utter tumult that was 2020—21.
Fear. Is there anything you can do, brave educator, to stop it?
In her daily column, Heather Cox Richardson drew parallels between McCarthyism in the 1950s, and the current pushback against an actively progressive government:
WI Senator Joe McCarthy__insisted that the country was made up of “Liberals,” who were guiding the nation toward socialism, and “Conservatives,” who were standing alone against the Democrats and Republicans who made up a majority of the country and liked the new business regulations, safety net, and infrastructure.
Sound familiar? Needless fear. It’s a good reminder, however, that we’ve been to this rodeo before, as citizens. And as public school educators:
Banned books. Sex education. Insertion/deletion of religion into school practices. Girls’ sports. Hairstyle battles. Student protests against [you name it]. New math. Drugs in schools. Teacher salaries. Remote, hybrid or face to face. Whole language vs. phonics.
It’s always something. Public schools are where a community’s fears and aspirations for their children and the future play out. It’s one of the few places where citizens can confront the elected peers who are making decisions about taxpayer-funded community goods.
And for attention-seekers, public schools are low-hanging fruit. Here’s how Tucker Carlson recalls his first-grade teacher:
The Fox host had written that his distaste for liberals began at seven years old, with his teacher Marianna Raymond — a “parody of mother-earth liberalism” who “wore long Indian-print skirts.” He claimed Raymond eschewed “conventional academic topics, like reading and penmanship,” and would sob “theatrically” at her desk. “Mrs. Raymond never did teach us [to read]; my father had to hire a tutor to get me through phonics,” Carlson wrote in Ship of Fools. His “sojourn as a conservative thinker” began shortly thereafter, adds the Post.
Raymond, however, has a completely different account of Carlson’s time in her class at the affluent La Jolla Country Day School. She remembers Carlson as “very precious and very, very polite and sweet,” and denies sobbing at her desk, wearing an Indian skirt, or venturing into political territory at all. What’s more, not only did she teach Carlson reading in the classroom — she was later hired to tutor him at home, the Post reports.
If you’ve been a public school teacher for a few years, you’ll recognize the nastiness in Tucker Carlson’s tone. It’s the old trope: Everyone went to school; therefore, everyone thinks they’re an expert.
What is Tucker Carlson, really? A distraction.
A distraction with millions of viewers, certainly—but if we were to draw up a list of what needs doing right now, for kids, and what teachers are saying about the upcoming year, it would never include combat over Critical Race Theory, since nine out of ten teachers say they’ve never taught it.
What should we be working on? Vaccination rates—all vaccinations, not just COVID. Safety protocols. Finding enough qualified staff. More recess and free play. Mental health for kids. Civil rights, as academic content and high-interest current event. Using the arts to help children understand and cope with a pandemic. Getting books into kids’ hands.
We can’t count on our organizations to solve our problems, although they have stepped up to help on the CRT front. Ultimately, however, issues have to be addressed school by school, classroom by classroom. Because that’s where the real juice is—in the interactions between teachers and students.
If a teacher rightly has any power at all, it is the power of Now. It isn’t the power of hierarchy, of being right, of being in charge. Now is the ultimate power of seizing an opportunity. The children with whom I work already understand this power much more fully than do I. Now is the natural habitat of the very young and it is where teachers must go if we are to be any good at all. That is where the power is.
So forget about Tucker Carlson. Really.
What a mean-spirited, little man that he would use lies about his first grade teacher to push his own agenda.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I know, right?
Also might be relevant to state that La Jolla Country Day School is a private school.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah–and that brings up another relevant point: many of the harshest public school critics base their beliefs around what teachers ‘should’ be/do on their own private-school experiences. When my daughter went to an all-girls Catholic school, I was shocked at how unresponsive the school was–I thought private schools would constantly be trying to please the parents who paid tuition. But that wasn’t even remotely true. Their attitude seemed to be: You’re lucky to be here (and not the terrible public schools)–so you have nothing to say about our policies or practice.
Thanks for sharing. That’s very true and apparently what Carlson does here.
Catholic schools also sometimes have pretty large class sizes.
I’ve had 2 job offers at prestigious private schools, one in Orlando and another in Memphis, to work with students with disabilities. I did not accept for several reasons, but it was implied that if the students couldn’t improve, they would be let go. This is very different from public schools, where we will continue to work with all students no matter their learning difficulties.
Currently and satisfyingly reading “The Autobiography of Malcom X”! (Playing catch-up a lot these days.)
I was stunned to learn that Tucker’s son Bucky is on the staff of Jim Banks, one of the two congress people Speaker Pelosi rejected for her bi-partisan committee to investigate the January 6 Insurrection. Such incestuous little circles in today’s right wing media and political world.
Thanks for this post, Nancy.
Glad you liked it. Google Buckley Carlson’s picture. He got the job with Banks when he was 23, a new graduate of the U of Virginia. His first job.