Consolidation. Is this the Answer to Closing Down Schools?

Being born in the heart of the Baby Boom, I spent my entire academic life watching new schools be built to accommodate the deluge of kids needing a public school education. In the third grade, I attended school in the completed wing of an in-progress structure that later became my high school. In my freshman year at a public university, five of us lived in a room designed for four, because the four new dorms being built to house the flood of students weren’t completed.

Then I became a public school teacher. In the 30-odd years I taught in Hartland, Michigan, the district built five brand new buildings, tore down one built in 1921, and refurbished four older buildings to accommodate new preschool and childcare programs and administrative functions. I’ve taught in double shifts and in a portable, where snow drifted in around the leaky windows. Because of what we called overcrowding.

Schools have always had to deal with fluctuation in student populations. There are any number of reasons why public schools lose kids, from demographic shifts away from urban or rural schools that were once thriving—to the rising impact of school “choice” (a word that requires scare quotes).

Big education news in the NYT this week, about school closures—with genuinely scary news about how inevitable these closures are:

Americans worried about soaring prices and pessimistic about the future are having fewer children or forgoing parenthood altogether, and the Trump administration’s immigration crackdown has meant fewer immigrants are arriving and enrolling their children in public schools.

Evidently, you can run but you can’t hide from successful schools randomly closing, even in the upscale neighborhood you selected because you loved the school. Although a crew of equally upscale neighbors attending Board meetings may put off the inevitable.

School closures are the ultimate betrayal for families who have invested in their public schools—investments that include PTA, field trips, fund-raisers and seats on the local school board, not to mention moving into that district because the schools had a good reputation.

On paper, of course, feelings about a particular school community mean nothing. What matters are efficiency, running lean fiscally and raising (or preserving) test scores. The things that parents are focused on—sports and mascots, outstanding teachers, special programs for their kids, being part of a school community—not so much.

There are many studies and how-to pieces on merging—or consolidating / pairing / clustering, take your pick—disparate school communities, whether individual schools in a district, or multiple districts. And—surprise!—while some show positive gains in efficiency, others demonstrate that consolidation is a lot of work, and doesn’t really save money.

Merging districts remains unpopular. Experts say consolidation is hard for several reasons: residents like the identity of their local schools, there are logistical challenges and managing joint debt is tricky.

Michigan has had a robust school choice policy for decades and has been charter-friendly since the mid-90s. There are 370-ish charter schools in Michigan, serving 11% of the K-12 population, and 540 public school districts.

A whole lot of the districts in Michigan that the casual observer might think are ripe for consolidation got that way because of the abundant “choices” in schooling, and the parents who move their children from school to school.

One could suggest that the first step—before consolidation—might be shutting down the easy opportunity to open a charter school, further reducing the tax base of surrounding public districts. But the legislators turn instead to consolidation, which is the anti-choice. They focus on the logistical tasks and tax/debt solutions. Problems that can be solved—not mere loyalties. Feelings.

Stakeholders whose schools were consolidated will tell you it can take a decade or more before kids and parents feel at home, before a community with common friendships and values is formed. Before the new school has an identity.

And those years are a big chunk of a child’s K-12 education.

As it happens, I live in a small rural county where consolidation talk bubbles up every year.
There are about 2600 kids, aged 5 to 18, living here. There are also four K-12 school districts, one K-12 Catholic school, a K-8 charter school and two private, independent schools (a HS which offers boarding plus a K-8 day school). The Grand Traverse Band of Ottawa and Chippewa Indians also has a reservation in this county. There are a lot of options for a diverse pool of students.

There is significant disparity between the four public districts. All of the schools—public, charter, parochial and independent—have distinct profiles, in terms of financial stability, programming, family involvement and family income. Their state-provided per-pupil funding base also varies significantly, with one district spending almost three times what another district gets.

And yet—each of the schools has some showcase programs, and modern facilities. I’ve been in all of them, as volunteer or substitute teacher, and found solid staffing and people determined to serve kids well in every school (including the Catholic and charter schools).

How do you account for that when you’re trying to re-route buses, feed kids more efficiently and order supplies? Or—and this is what most consolidation advocates are worried about—merge two levels of school debt?

Which bottom line matters most—family satisfaction or equalizing the numbers?

Leave a Reply